Brewster by the Sea is hands down the best B&B I've ever experienced. The accommodations, ambiance, food, and hosts – all are off the charts. Hosts include consummate... read more innkeeper/owner Amy, breakfast server par excellence Kelsie, the wonderful staff behind the scenes, and the sweet and gentle dog Sweet Pea. I stayed in the Refugio Suite in the Orchard House, a roomy two-room suite with a separate door opening to a small backyard deck. I was greeted by a small bouquet of fresh flowers, a folder full of useful information about the area, and an excellent guidebook about the Cape. The furnishings were impeccable. There were comfortable chairs and sofa and an antique desk as well as a beautiful sleigh headboard and matching dresser in the bedroom. Little inlaid leaves adorned both pieces. Attention to detail is one of Amy's hallmarks. I was pleased to try the handcrafted chemical and preservative-free shampoo and conditioner bars (like soap bars) offered in the bathroom. Same for the linen towels provided along with regular terry cloth towels for the less adventurous. The linen towels are a real find; they absorb water faster than traditional towels and dry much faster. Every one of the breakfasts was superb. The first course was a fresh fruit medley – including cantaloupe, blackberries, raspberries, peaches, and citrus blend of orange and grapefruit – plus a muffin or breakfast cake. The main offerings when I was there included avocado toast with perfectly cooked poached eggs, brioche French toast, pumpkin pancakes, and an egg, cheese, and scallion mix cooked in a ramekin, plus bacon or sausage ... you get the idea. Alternatives are offered for non-meat eaters and those following a gluten-free diet. In the afternoon in the lobby, cookies and pastries were available, along with an assortment of liqueurs. Amy is a lovely, low-key host who's always willing to offer suggestions for restaurants and activities, and is happy to share stories about her life and adventures. She creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere in a lovely, impeccably decorated, and immaculately clean historic property, and makes every guest feel special. My stay far exceeded expectations, and I will be delighted to return. Most highly recommended!

  Thank you so very much - from all of us here at BBTS! We enjoyed hosting you, and look forward to next time! Warmest wishes, Amy, Kelsie, Sawyer... read more and Sweet Pea!!

  This was our second stay at this incredible Inn and we are thrilled to say that it actually exceeded our expectations from our last visit, which wasn’t easy to do!... read more Amy is the new owner, and with her precious dog aptly named “Sweet Pea,” we couldn’t have felt more welcomed or had a more outstanding stay! This place was great before, but Amy has taken the accommodation details to a new level of excellence! Everything has been thought of to make our stay there in line with, or better than, some 5 star establishments we have stayed at! She has thought of everything anyone could possibly need, and it’s this attention to detail and comfort that makes this place exceptional in every way! From the high end bathroom toiletries including the best locally made soaps, shampoos and conditioners, to the welcome goodies, and the convenience of bottles of water, and tea and coffee always nearby, with afternoon cookies and cakes, every need was tended to. And did we mention the exceptionally delicious home made gourmet breakfasts?!! And she even ensured equally delicious tasting Gluten Free options! And the room we were given was exceptional also. Spotless, roomy, and supremely comfortable with a gas fireplace for a cool night with a soothing color palette and a separate sitting area. It felt like we were in a very high end establishment at a fraction of the costs that come with this kind of comfort. Amy has simply thought of everything and as a result she has taken this place to another level. We can easily say without exception that this establishment is one of the best B&B’s we have ever experienced! It is located in Brewster, an area close to everything so we could see all the top spots on the Cape with ease. And of course Amy thought of ensuring that there were maps, information and anything else needed to ensure we knew the best places to go, and all the restaurants and travel spots that would enhance our stay. We cannot think of one thing lacking, and are truly amazed at what Amy is willing to offer at these great rates that exceed what you may find at places that are much more pricey and have much less to offer. Truly a find, and an exceptional Inn that warrants a top rating for a stay that is easily one of the best places we have ever stayed at, on the Cape or elsewhere. If you want comfort, convenience, great amenities and exceptional breakfasts with a lovely welcoming host who will go out of her way to make your stay the best it could be, this is the place to come to. We recommend it highly and will definitely come back regularly.
Thank you Amy! We look forward to our next visit to the beautiful Brewster By the Sea Inn. Our thanks also to “Sweet Pea” for being such a loving, gentle and welcoming “co-host” herself!
Linda and Paul Morelli

  We stayed for four blissful nights with Amy and the team at this fabulous Inn. They really have thought of everything. Brewster is a lovely little settlement on the quieter... read more side of the Cape and the Inn is situated in a lovely garden. It was too late in the year for us to take advantage of the outdoor pool, but we enjoyed taking our breakfast every morning in the lovely, light-filled sitting room. And what a breakfast! Two courses, an appetiser and a main, which through our stay included raspberry brioche French toast, avocado toast with perfectly poached eggs and bacon confetti and zucchini frittata. Wow! My only complaint is that I will probably have gone up a dress size on my return home. Amy employs a chef and his expertise was very evident.
But it’s the small touches that make this such a lovely place to stay. Amy made a note of our favourite teas and ensured that these were available by the kettle available for making drinks whenever we wanted. She brought out china cups rather than chunky mugs so we enjoyed the tea more.
Our room was delightful, spacious and comfortable. Beautifully decorated, with a view over the garden and a large, comfy bed. We really appreciated the peaceful atmosphere: the Inn is directly on the 6A but we heard no road noise at all during our stay.
What we liked best about our stay was Amy’s quiet and charming hospitality. She was happy to talk a bit about her background and how she’d moved into inn-keeping, and if asked to provide great recommendations for places to visit, activities and restaurants. She’s a great listener and has a real knack for making you feel at home. She’s passing on these skills to the next generation, the youngsters at Brewster were equally charming.
Lastly, I just want to call out the Inn for the great value it represents. We stayed in more expensive places during our trip, but Brewster was out and out the best.
We live a long way away and probably won’t return, but we’d unreservedly recommend this place to anyone considering a trip to the Cape. Thank you Amy and team (not forgetting Sweet Pea) for looking after us so we’ll.

  Yes, the place is pristine . Yes, the lobby is warm and inviting. Yes, the room provided everything needed....and more, including premium towels and linens, the best in hair care... read more and body soaps. But what sets this inn apart from the rest is the heart and soul of the place - Amy and her staff. She is not your garden variety innkeeper, although she maintains a beautiful garden. She anticipates well in advance what her guests will enjoy and then executes flawlessly. And her dog, Sweet Pea, is the gift that keeps on giving - a real team player. It was my first trip to Cape Cod, truly a memorable time. If you choose Brewster by the Sea, you will not be disappointed. You will have more than a stay, you will experience a special blessing.

  We only were able to stay one night here, but it was a great experience. The room was immaculate, with a large king bed, gas burning fireplace and immaculate... read more bathroom with regular and linen towels and a small comfortable sitting area.
Amy was a wonderful host, providing tips around Cape Cod area, and great suggestions for local restaurants.
The breakfast was superb, with fresh fruit, mango banana bread as a starter, then brioche french toast and sausage to finish it off.
If we get a chance to come back to Cape Cod, we'll definitely stay here again and would recommend it to everyone!