About Our Historic Cape Cod Inn

Our beautiful nine-room Inn is one of the best places to stay on Cape Cod and offers first-class lodging accommodations, providing simple elegance and warm hospitality — a place where our guests are the focus of our attention. We offer rooms and suites in the original 1846 home, as well as in our more modern Orchard House. 

Our philosophy is simple:

  • We believe in old-fashioned, warm hospitality, and want to exceed your expectations!
  • Our breakfasts use the freshest ingredients and are familiar yet gourmet.  We maintain requested favorites, and are always trying something new in our test-kitchen.

About Your Innkeepers

In the fall of 2016, Amy Chesnut purchased Brewster By The Sea Inn.  The Cape has been a part of Amy’s life since she was a toddler, and she always knew she would end up living here permanently.  In her previous life, Amy had a fulfilling 30-year career in non-profit land conservation in Portland, Oregon and Sonoma County, California.  She was born and raised in Westchester County, New York. 

In August of 2019, Amy was thrilled to welcome her son, Sawyer and his fiancee, Kelsie, as part of the team here at Brewster By The Sea Inn.  Sawyer and Kelsie met at the University of Hawaii — Kelsie was born on the Island of Oahu and raised on Maui.  The wedding date has been set for September 26, 2020!  

Sweet Pea is the most beloved member of the team — by guests especially.  Amy adopted then 5-year-old Sweet Pea just before moving to the Inn.  Sweet Pea is a black lab/shepherd mix, and is always available for some dog therapy for guests who are missing their pets.



9.9 Rated by Guests